Gary Neville: Why Man Utd Still Struggle Under New Management | OneFootball

Neville Points Out “Red Flags” in Amorim’s Man Utd Debut

New Beginnings Fall Flat

Manchester United’s so-called new era, under Ruben Amorim, began with a tepid 1-1 draw at Ipswich Town—a performance that has done little to ease the mounting anxieties among supporters. Gary Neville, a club legend and prominent pundit, has wasted no time in identifying “red flags” in United’s display, suggesting the issues run far deeper than the arrival of a new manager.

The match itself unfolded in familiar fashion for United. Marcus Rashford’s sharp finish from Amad Diallo’s cross gave the visitors an early lead, a moment of quality that hinted at better things to come. However, that hope was short-lived as Omari Hutchinson’s deflected strike levelled the game before half-time. Ipswich, struggling at the foot of the table, often looked the better-organised side, while United relied on Andre Onana’s heroics in goal to leave Suffolk with a point.

Photo: IMAGO

Tactical Confusion and Ongoing Struggles

Amorim, in his post-match comments, admitted his players looked “confused” at times as they adjusted to his preferred 3-4-3 system. The 39-year-old was forthright in warning that his side would “suffer” as they adapted to his methods, but the early signs were not encouraging. Even Roy Keane, another former United captain, dismissed the current team as an “average Premier League side.”

Neville, speaking on Sky Sports, provided a scathing yet measured analysis of the problems. “The red flags that were there yesterday would have been there probably for the last few months and the last season and a half of a team that are very difficult to actually like watching,” he remarked.

Photo: IMAGO

He added: “You look at Ipswich, very near the bottom of the league, and they looked more organised, better coached. They looked like they had more appetite for the game, more enthusiasm.”

A Systemic Issue

The concerns Neville raised are not new, nor are they limited to Amorim’s tenure. For over two years, United have failed to form an identity, let alone deliver consistent performances. According to Neville, this inconsistency has become an intrinsic part of the squad’s DNA.

“This is a pattern that these players have created for themselves,” Neville explained. “The same things we’ve seen over the last six, eight, ten months, we saw yesterday. Ruben Amorim saw it too.”

Photo IMAGO

These comments underline the enormity of the challenge facing Amorim. The squad’s potential remains undeniable, yet the lack of cohesion and intensity has become a recurring theme.

What Lies Ahead

Manchester United’s schedule offers little respite. On Thursday, they host Bodo/Glimt in the Europa League—a competition they may now be forced to prioritise. Everton, another team battling inconsistency, visit Old Trafford on Sunday.

The path forward for Amorim will be a test of his managerial prowess and his ability to instil discipline and belief in a squad that seems to lack both. As Neville’s words suggest, turning things around at Old Trafford will take more than new systems or fresh ideas; it requires an entire cultural reset.