Player Ratings as 10-Man Manchester United Stun Arsenal in Penalty Shootout

EPL Index

·12 January 2025

Player Ratings as 10-Man Manchester United Stun Arsenal in Penalty Shootout

Thrilling FA Cup Encounter Sees Manchester United Triumph over Arsenal on Penalties

In a dramatic showdown at the Emirates Stadium, Manchester United emerged victorious, defeating Arsenal 5-3 in a penalty shootout following a 1-1 draw in the FA Cup third round. This gripping match was filled with moments of high tension and tactical intrigue, making it a spectacle for the fans.

Early Lead and Comeback Drama

The match kicked off with intense pressure as both teams vied for control. Manchester United seized the initiative in the second half when Bruno Fernandes converted a superb first-time shot into the corner of the net, courtesy of Alejandro Garnacho’s slick assist. However, Arsenal responded stoutly; Gabriel Magalhaes’ deflected shot levelled the scores shortly after Diogo Dalot received his marching orders for a second bookable offence, altering the dynamics of the game.

OneFootball Videos

Photo: IMAGO

Key Performances and Missed Opportunities

With the teams locked at 1-1 after regular and extra time, the spotlight turned to individual performances. Arsenal’s Martin Odegaard was thwarted by Altay Bayindir, Manchester United’s goalkeeper, who denied him from the penalty spot. Both Kai Havertz and Declan Rice had golden opportunities to clinch the game for Arsenal during the added periods, but they failed to convert their chances, setting the stage for a nerve-wracking penalty shootout.

Penalty Shootout Showdown

In the decisive penalty shootout, Arsenal faltered while Manchester United displayed clinical efficiency, converting all their attempts. The standout performer was undoubtedly Bayindir, whose heroic saves during the game and in the shootout earned him the ‘Player of the Match’ accolade.

Player Ratings Breakdown

Arsenal

David Raya (GK): 6
Jurrien Timber (RB): 7
William Saliba (CB): 7
Gabriel (CB): 8
Myles Lewis-Skelly (LB): 7
Jorginho (DM): 7
Mikel Merino (CM): 7
Martin Odegaard (CM, c): 8
Gabriel Jesus (RW): 6
Kai Havertz (CF): 8
Gabriel Martinelli (LW): 7
Raheem Sterling (Sub): 7
Declan Rice (Sub): 7
Leandro Trossard (Sub): 6
Thomas Partey (Sub): 7
Kieran Tierney (Sub): Not applicable

Manchester United

Altay Bayindir (GK): 9
Matthijs de Ligt (CB): 7
Harry Maguire (CB): 7
Lisandro Martinez (CB): 7
Noussair Mazraoui (RWB): 7
Manuel Ugarte (CM): 6
Kobbie Mainoo (CM): 7
Diogo Dalot (LWB): 5
Alejandro Garnacho (AM): 8
Bruno Fernandes (AM): 8
Rasmus Hojlund (CF): 6
Amad Diallo (Sub): 6
Toby Collyer (Sub): 6
Joshua Zirkzee (Sub): 6
Tyrell Malacia (Sub): 7
Leny Yoro (Sub): 6

Reflection on a Classic Encounter

This match was more than just a third-round fixture; it was a testament to the tactical battles, individual brilliance, and the thin margins that define top-level football. Both Arsenal and Manchester United demonstrated why the FA Cup remains one of the most beloved competitions in the sport. With United advancing to the fourth round, they keep alive their hopes of adding another illustrious chapter to their storied FA Cup history.