Three coaches, turbulence and stand-outs: Roma insider lifts lid on Milan’s opponents | OneFootball

AC Milan will play their final game of 2024 tonight and they will do so in front of a big home crowd, hoping to beat Roma and end the year well.

Milan did win their last game before the festive break against Hellas Verona, but it was a far from convincing performance and the team ultimately remain down in eighth place in the table.

To get the lowdown on Roma amid what has already been quite a chaotic season, we spoke to Samuel Bannister who runs ‘Giallorossi Yorkshire’ – a fan site for Romanisti in the north of England – for our preview.

Roma decided to continue with Daniele De Rossi after his caretaker stint but he was sacked relatively early on in the campaign. Was it the right call, and is there some regret giving him a long-term deal?

“De Rossi did well at first in caretaker charge, winning eight of his first 10 games, but I think the first mistake was announcing he’d be staying in charge before that spell was over.

“It was intended to give a short-term boost, but then results started to dip before the end of last season, and yet the club were already committed, even though he actually hadn’t signed his contract by that point.

“Thus, with some doubts starting to creep in, it didn’t compute that the club then gave him a long-term, three-year contract if they had their hesitations. Yet to sack him four games into the new season, and that aforementioned new contract, really shook things up.

“Much of Roma’s instability this season can be traced back to that point, with the decision widely seen as a mistake, not necessarily because he was an outstanding coach or the right person for the job, but because of how it shocked and unsettled the squad and fanbase.”

More Stories / Features

Warnings, media distrust and the great conflict: Five extracts from Cardinale’s interview analysed

23 December 2024, 20:00

Milan stars, management and Fonscea face the people’s court: What the verdict returned

18 December 2024, 19:00

Crosshairs, culprits and threats: What was behind Fonseca’s brutal post-match rant

12 December 2024, 16:10

Ivan Juric then came in, what was the reaction to that and what didn’t work for him?

“The reaction at the time was mixed, but generally negative. The fanbase were dissatisfied for what had happened to De Rossi, so whoever came in next was set up to struggle to win them over. There had also been whispers of arguably more inspiring replacements, but things developed quickly.

“That said, Juric had recently been a respected mid-table Serie A coach, and not a relegation battler as some critics perceived. Some felt he deserved a chance in a job like this. Maybe if De Rossi had been thanked and let go in the summer and Juric had worked with the squad over pre-season, it might have worked better.

“On paper, he wasn’t as incapable as the ensuing results suggested. But he failed to impose his preferred tactics and there were some embarrassing performances and results, such as losing to Elfsborg in the Europa League and Hellas Verona in Serie A.

“He was fighting a losing battle from fairly early on in the job and struggled to inspire much confidence that he could get out of it. Roma fans had become desensitised to ruthless sackings by this point and it wasn’t a surprise to see him dismissed.”

Roma favourite Claudio Ranieri returned, is it a case of him being a stabiliser and trying to rescue a season from crisis?

“The name Claudio Ranieri and the word ‘stability’ go hand in hand when it comes to Roma. He took a tempestuous situation – abandoning his well-earned retirement to do so, such is his bond with this club – and has restored a sense of calmness.

“He did the same last time he was in charge in a caretaker role in 2019. Unlike then, this time there is starting to be some faint conversation of him being a contender to remain in charge next season as well if Roma struggle to attract a high-level upgrade, which is nice recognition for him even though I would be surprised at this stage if it unfolds that way.

“Once again, results will have to be judged over the long term, but Ranieri has restored some simplicity in Roma’s approach in the right way and senior players like Mats Hummels and Leandro Paredes have gone from being regularly left out to becoming key players again.

“There will still be bad results over the next few months as well as some good ones, but as you say, that sense of ‘crisis’ seems to have dissipated.”

Photo by Marco Luzzani/Getty Images

Is this Roma squad hugely underperforming or does it have big flaws? Also, what was your opinion on the summer business done?

“I would say a bit of both for the first question. Ranieri has started to show there is more talent in this squad than performances (and selection decisions) previously suggested. At the same time, this is a flawed squad that hasn’t been constructed well – which comes back to the second question.

“I strongly believe the summer transfer window was a massive missed opportunity for Roma. There were fewer Financial Fair Play restrictions than previous years and lots of players who were on loan needed replacing, so Roma ended up spending more than they had in a number of years.

“With the confidence they put in De Rossi, it was a chance to build the squad he wanted. But, maybe because he didn’t have a fully fleshed-out system yet either, Roma bought a bunch of players who didn’t appear to fit together.

“A lot of those players are good, there’s no denying that, but it was hard to see the vision and it’s led to players like Matias Soulé and Enzo Le Fée struggling to cement their place. It was like if a cook had a lot of good individual ingredients that just didn’t go together to make a meal.

“What’s more, some areas of need that were seen as priorities before the summer, such as a strong starting right-back and more pace on the wings, were left unaddressed.

“But of the new signings, Manu Koné (arguably Roma’s best player this season) and to a lesser extent Artem Dovbyk, Hummels and a certain Alexis Saelemaekers have had some redeeming qualities so far (in addition to Angeliño whose loan was sensibly made permanent).”

What have been the high and low points of the campaign to this point?

“There have been more lows than highs, notably the loss to Elfsborg I mentioned earlier, but also the 5-1 loss to Fiorentina, especially when one of the players we let go in the summer, Edoardo Bove, was running the show for the opponents.

“Even since Ranieri returned, there’s been a loss to Como. But this has also been where some of the higher points have been; beating Lecce 4-1 and Parma 5-0 earlier this month, regardless of the stature of opposition, have restored some confidence.

“I’d even put the 2-2 draw with Tottenham in the Europa League up there in terms of how we changed our approach and gained more self-belief because of it.”

More Stories / The Match

GdS: Fonseca’s chosen one now benched – Abraham’s rollercoaster first few months

29 December 2024, 18:22

No league defeats in nine meetings: All the key stats ahead of Milan vs. Roma

29 December 2024, 16:45

Three coaches, turbulence and stand-outs: Roma insider lifts lid on Milan’s opponents

29 December 2024, 15:20

What is the outside perspective on Milan, and how did you react to Paulo Fonseca getting the job?

“I’d see this game as a good indicator of where we’re both at as both teams are falling below expectations this season. It’s winnable for either.

“I was surprised at the choice of Fonseca by Milan as the departure of Pioli left me thinking the plan would be to bring in a significant upgrade, which I don’t believe Fonseca is. I was equally surprised he took on the risk of coming back to Serie A given that he struggled with Roma before but seemed to be doing better in France.

“Maybe he felt he had a point to prove, because at Roma I felt he showed some tactical naivety and stubbornness to ideas that weren’t working, which he was too slow to change. I’m not surprised he’s been under pressure at Milan and I’m intrigued to see him up against Ranieri, who he replaced at Roma.

“In hindsight, I would have preferred to keep Ranieri back then as I don’t think Fonseca improved us, perhaps similar to how he hasn’t improved Milan post-Pioli yet.”

Are there any injuries/other selection problems? What is the starting line-up likely to be?

“The main absentee through injury at the moment is Bryan Cristante, who was in danger of losing his starting role anyway so it hasn’t changed the plans too much.

“Ranieri has also been cutting back on how much captain Lorenzo Pellegrini is being used, so don’t be surprised not to see him in the starting lineup. The formation recently has been a variation between a 3-4-2-1 or a 3-5-2, with the three centre-backs being a settled choice.

“Last week the lineup was: Svilar; Mancini, Hummels, Ndicka; Saelemaekers, Koné, Paredes, Angeliño; Dybala, El Shaarawy; Dovbyk. Ranieri didn’t make any subs, so he might go for the same lineup again.

“The only way he may change it would be putting Niccolò Pisilli in as another midfield body, probably instead of El Shaarawy. But I imagine about all but one or two shirts are safe, especially after winning 5-0 last week.”

Who have Roma’s key performers been?

“Roma’s two best players this season have been Manu Koné, who has given the midfield what it was lacking for a long time, and Mile Svilar in goal.

“Evan Ndicka has improved in defence too so may be the toughest obstacle for Milan. In recent weeks, Paulo Dybala, Leandro Paredes and Saelemaekers have been coming into form, so watch out for them.

“Dovbyk is also someone to be wary of up front, he’s been hot and cold so far (more cold than hot in the last few weeks!) but is the leading scorer so isn’t someone to discount.”