Nottingham Forest And Tottenham Want Manchester City Youngster: What Should Pep Guardiola Do? | OneFootball

Manchester City News: James McAtee is once again on the radar of several Premier League clubs. The 22-year-old playmaker has quietly caught the eye without making headlines, but has performed consistently whenever he has been given minutes with Manchester City’s first team. Last season, despite limited opportunities under Pep Guardiola, he managed to score seven goals in all competitions, making it clear that he is not short of talent. McAtee’s name is now being linked with both Nottingham Forest and Tottenham as per TBR Football, two teams with different ambitions but a common interest: to add young, promising quality to their squads.

Nottingham Forest And Tottenham Want Manchester City Player James McAtee

Manchester City know they have a special player on their hands, but are also clear that McAtee’s growth needs real minutes. Nottingham Forest see him as an option to bolster an attack that could be without Morgan Gibbs-White, while Tottenham are looking for attacking options with promise to strengthen their immediate future. McAtee can play inside or out, has a goal, mobility, and offers that spark that many coaches value.

Forest offer him a clear opportunity to play week in, week out, something that could weigh heavily if the player prioritises his development. Tottenham, on the other hand, would give him a bigger window, albeit with more internal competition. Both scenarios have appeal, but do not mean the same thing for his career at the moment.

From Manchester City’s point of view, the decision should not just be about finances. McAtee represents a generation of players who have grown up under the club’s system, and letting him go without guarantees of a buy-back would be a mistake. If City decide to sell him, they should include a clause that allows them to take him back if he fulfils his potential in another team.

What should Pep Guardiola’s side do?

Loaning him out is not a bad idea either, as long as the destination is one where he plays regularly and continues to develop in a competitive environment. The case of Elanga or Hudson-Odoi at Forest shows that the surroundings matter. To sell him without guarantees would be to dispense with a chip that could be worth much more in two years. It is also important to appreciate what it means for the dressing room to maintain a real avenue for young players to break into the first team. If McAtee does not find space, other home-grown talent may lose motivation.

So, Manchester City need to act with a cool head. Selling him to Forest with buy-back clause could benefit all parties. Selling him to Tottenham without a buy-back option might seem profitable today, but risky tomorrow. If there is one thing the club must avoid, it is repeating past mistakes with youngsters who left early. James McAtee has shown he can give more, and he just needs a club to give him the space and continuity to prove it.