Report: Could Arsenal Swoop for West Ham’s Technical Director? | OneFootball

Arsenal’s Sporting Director Void Sparks Concerns Over West Ham’s Tim Steidten

As Edu’s sudden departure from Arsenal leaves the club in search of a new sporting director, whispers about potential replacements have already begun circulating. Among them, West Ham’s technical director, Tim Steidten, has emerged as a possible candidate. Such a move raises significant concerns among West Ham supporters, given their team’s inconsistent form and the questionable success of Steidten’s recent signings.

In an article by The Telegraph, this possibility is discussed in the context of Steidten’s track record and West Ham’s ongoing struggles. West Ham fans may rightly wonder if Steidten’s time in east London has been productive enough to warrant such attention from a rival club. Arsenal’s approach to filling Edu’s void, however, remains cautious, as the club weighs its options before making a definitive move.

Arsenal’s Sporting Director Conundrum

Edu’s exit from Arsenal has sent ripples through the club. Serving since 2019 and ascending to sporting director in 2022, Edu played a pivotal role in the club’s recent resurgence, working closely with Mikel Arteta to forge a unified vision. Edu’s decision to leave was unexpected, reportedly influenced by the opportunity to take on a high-profile position in a multi-club structure, which Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis is spearheading.

Photo IMAGO

“Edu’s departure will not affect the plan and vision for Arsenal,” Arteta reassured fans, attempting to assuage concerns about a possible disruption. Nevertheless, Edu’s sudden exit has left a void that Arsenal is keen to fill with a careful approach, hoping to maintain the balance within their executive structure.

The Arsenal board has yet to decide on a like-for-like replacement, leaving open the possibility of a reshaped role. The team’s co-chairman Josh Kroenke, along with other key executives, are expected to engage in strategic discussions during the international break to define their next steps.

Tim Steidten’s Rollercoaster at West Ham

For Arsenal, Steidten might appear to be a competent candidate due to his experience as West Ham’s technical director since July 2023. However, West Ham fans might argue otherwise. Steidten’s tenure has not been smooth, with mixed outcomes from a costly transfer window and an unsettling start to the season.

Working alongside West Ham’s sporting director Mark Noble, Steidten has been responsible for player recruitment, particularly during the club’s £100 million spending spree over the summer. Despite this hefty investment, the results have been underwhelming, with West Ham languishing in the lower half of the Premier League table and performances failing to meet expectations.

Several of Steidten’s signings have not lived up to their billing, notably Guido Rodriguez from Real Betis. Some of these acquisitions were reportedly on new manager Julen Lopetegui’s wish list, but others, chosen by Steidten, have failed to ignite excitement among fans or deliver substantial impact on the pitch.

Photo IMAGO

Yet, even amid concerns over his recruitment choices, there is resistance within the West Ham hierarchy to see Steidten leave. If Arsenal were to make a move for Steidten, West Ham would reportedly seek to retain him, highlighting the club’s belief in his potential despite recent setbacks.

Lopetegui and Steidten: A Complicated Relationship

Steidten’s influence within West Ham has only grown since David Moyes left the club. Lopetegui, who was brought in after Moyes’ departure, wasn’t necessarily Steidten’s first choice, sparking speculation about potential disagreements within the club. Nonetheless, Lopetegui has thus far retained his position, even amid a difficult start to the season. According to The Telegraph, “Lopetegui is under pressure after a disappointing start… but will remain in charge whatever the result of Saturday’s Premier League home game against Everton.”

Photo IMAGO

This delicate balance between the director and manager is likely an area of concern for West Ham’s board and supporters alike. The relationship between Steidten and Lopetegui is crucial to the club’s future direction, and any disruption to their collaboration could further destabilise West Ham’s season. Additionally, the lack of cohesion between signings aligned with Lopetegui’s preferences and those selected by Steidten raises questions about long-term vision and strategic alignment.

Why Arsenal Might Hold Back on a Steidten Approach

For Arsenal, appointing Steidten could be seen as a risk given his limited success at West Ham. Arsenal has the advantage of a strong executive team, which may afford them time to avoid a hasty decision and thoroughly evaluate all candidates. Furthermore, Jason Ayto, Edu’s former assistant, is expected to play a more prominent role in the interim, bridging any gaps until a final decision is made.

This cautious approach may also account for the complexities of extracting a senior executive from a rival club mid-season. The Gunners are reportedly exploring both internal and external candidates, signalling an openness to either promoting from within or bringing in fresh perspectives from elsewhere.

Meanwhile, Arsenal’s recent Champions League loss to Inter Milan and mounting challenges in the Premier League underscore the need for stability and cohesion. Amid growing pressure to keep their title hopes alive, a misstep in their search for Edu’s replacement could have significant implications.

Ultimately, Steidten’s name on the shortlist raises more questions than it answers, and Arsenal may choose to bide their time until a candidate with the right blend of experience, vision, and proven track record emerges.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

A West Ham Fan’s Perspective: Should Arsenal Really Consider Steidten?

Steidten’s short tenure has been underwhelming, with underperforming signings that have left fans questioning his judgement. While his role at the club was meant to be transformative, the reality is that results on the pitch are far from inspiring. West Ham has invested over £100 million, yet the return on this investment has been lacklustre, to say the least.

Steidten’s ability to drive meaningful change within the club has been put to the test, and the team’s league position leaves a lot to be desired. Players like Rodriguez have not delivered, and the inconsistent performances have kept the team hovering just above the relegation zone. Lopetegui’s apparent lack of alignment with Steidten on recruitment choices further complicates the picture, as fans witness the unsettling impact of poor planning and questionable transfers.

Letting Steidten leave might be a relief for some Hammers supporters, giving the club a chance to start afresh with someone more attuned to the club’s needs. However, if he were to leave, the timing would need to be right – West Ham can’t afford to lose a key figure without a solid replacement lined up.

If Arsenal proceeds with their pursuit of Steidten, West Ham fans might view it as an unexpected blessing. Whether it proves to be a wise decision for either club, however, remains to be seen.